Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation Office of the Chief Executive 4557 Melan Dr. S. Fairbanks, AK 99712 Thomas D. Selz Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz, PC 488 Madison Avenue New York, New York 10022 Voice: (212) 980-0120 Fax: (212) 593-9175 E-mail: dgonzalez@fkkslaw.com November 27, 2004 Dear Sirs: We have received your letter concerning Margaret Mitchell's book, "Gone with the Wind." To insure we have addressed all your concerns, we are including our responses interspersed with the items in your inquiry. *Our responses below are indicated by preceding *'s, *as in this sample line. OPENING STATEMENT: The Australian proprietors of PGA have no ownership or organizational connection with Project Gutenberg in the United States, nor is there any shared control in any manner of which eBooks are selected, which sites they are on, or any other aspects of their operation. If you have a complaint against Project Gutenberg of Australia, you are not, at present, contacting that organization, or with anyone who has a right to speak or act for them via your Certified Mail. Project Gutenberg itself operates under the United States copyright laws and has scrupulously respected existing copyrights for its entire history. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation only operates within the United States and under United States laws, and our legal advisors assure us we are operating correctly as per United States copyright law. Project Gutenberg's organizers have been friendly to those, like PGA, who wish to provide a similar library of public domain works in their own country, and complying with their own copyright laws. Because the Internet permits people from other countries to contact the Project Gutenberg site, and because some of the works on the U.S. site are public domain in the United States, but still protected under the laws of other countries, Project Gutenberg has tried to warn foreign users of our internet site that they need to comply with the copyright laws of their own country. This warning is not required by any law that we are aware of. Perhaps your complaint has some validity under Australian copyright law. We do not know, we are not expert in Australian copyright law, but we are not the proper party against whom to pursue such a complaint. We can assist you by providing a mailing address for Project Gutenberg of Australia on request. * Your original letter, and our responses to it, begin here. * Our replies each begin with an * preceding each relevant line. Subject: Copyright Infringement of Gone With the Wind October 25, 2004 Certified Mail- Return receipt Requested Project Gutenberg 405 West Elm Street Urbana, IL 61801 By e-mail (colc@gutenberg.net.au) Project Gutenberg of Australia Re: Copyright Infringement of Gone With the Wind To Whom It May Concern: We represent the Stephens Mitchell Trusts (the "Trusts"), the owner of the copyright to the book, Gone With The Wind ("GWTW"). There are copyright provisions around the world, including, without limitation, the United States Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. A7101 et. seq, which grant the Trusts, as copyright owner, the exclusive right to reproduce and distribute GWTW in the United States and elsewhere. * We have studied "the United States Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. A7101 * et. seq," at length, and have found no indication of any portion * applicable to this particular case. If you would care to point * out any specific portion you feel may be of interest, we should * be only too happy to re-examine that portion and related materials. It has come to our attention that Project Gutenberg's affiliate, Project Gutenberg of Australia ("PGA"), is publishing GWTW in electronic book form on its web site located at www.gutenberg.net.au (the "Web Site"). The Web Site states that PGA "produces etexts in accordance with Australian law" and that the books available on its site are in the public domain in Australia. While the Web Site warns that some of its ebooks may still be protected by copyright in the U.S. and suggests that U.S. users check U.S. copyright laws or visit Project Gutenberg's U.S. web site for its list of public domain works, there is nothing to prevent any U.S. user from simply downloading GWTW from the Web Site. Indeed, we were able to do so easily. * We are aware of no requirement that such sites place into effect ANY * notification that users in other countries check their own regional * copyright laws before downloading. This notice appears to be above * and beyond either the letter or the spirit of the law, and should * be commended, rather than the opposite. It appears to us that Project Gutenberg established PGA to permit the illegal downloading of works that are still subject to copyright protection in the U.S. and elsewhere. Project Gutenberg's and PGA's willful, knowing and unauthorized distribution of GWTW to users in the U.S. and elsewhere where copyright protection remains available is a blatant violation of our client's rights under applicable statutes and common law. Please be advised that Project Gutenberg and PGA are subject to U.S. copyright law and to jurisdiction in the U.S. for their infringing activities through applicable jurisdiction statutes governing the commission of acts of infringement that either occur in the U.S. or have an effect in the U.S. * Project Gutenberg [Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation] * has no legal or formal relationship with Project Gutenberg of * Australia, Project Runeberg, the Gutenberg Projekt-DE, * Project Gutenberg of the Philippines, Portugal, Canada, * or any of the thousands of Project Gutenberg sites outside the US. * We encourage everyone around the world to work within the copyright * under which they live, and to make as much of their own public domain * available as possible, up to and including the time when all of the * public domain materials in the world will be made available in their * original languages and in translation to 100 other languages. * The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation only controls sites * in the US, and these are of a minimal number, each of which also puts * up voluntary notices concerning the checking of local copyright laws. On behalf of the Trusts, we hereby demand that Project Gutenberg and/or PGA confirm to us within five (5) days of receipt of this letter that you have removed GWTW from the Web Site entirely or that you have taken all necessary steps to prevent the downloading of GWTW in all places in which it is protected by copyright. * We would be only too happy to assist you in the regions of the world * in which you still have the original copyright, or even in which the * right have been extended and re-extended, by writing a letter, which * you would be entitled to forward in such cases; to include with your * requests, stating that Project Gutenberg requests such eBooks not to * be republished in countries where they are still under copyright. Please be advised that if we have not received confirmation of your willingness to comply with the foregoing demands, we will take all appropriate steps to protect and enforce our clients' rights. This demand is without prejudice to all of the Trusts' rights and remedies in this matter, both legal and equitable, all of which are specifically and expressly reserved. * It would appear we have addressed all the appropriate claims * as per your request, and we hope you accept our cooperation * in the spirit in which it is offered. * If there is anything further we can do to help you with copyright * issues pursuant to this situation, please do not hesitate to ask. Sincerely, Dr. Gregory B. Newby, Chief Executive Officer The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation http://gutenberg.org A 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization with EIN 64-6221541 gbnewby@pglaf.org